• Home
  • About
  • Links

Feeds:
Posts
Comments
« Live from Netroots Nation ’09
Cash-for-clunkers program unproven »

Bloggers weigh in on our NPDB-hospital report

August 13, 2009 by Linda Kurtz

You know an issue is important when a variety of people have something to say about it.

It seems that our hospital report from late May has had this sort of effect. The report outlines our findings: Since 1990, when the National Practitioner Data Bank went online, hospitals have reported, on average, just 650 doctors a year that have been disciplined for unprofessional behavior or incompetence. That falls well short of the 5,000 annual reports anticipated when the database was created. Nearly 50 percent of all hospitals did not submit a single name to the database in its first 17 years.

Appalled at this apparent dismissal of the databank by hospitals around the country, we offered some powerful recommendations to fix the system, including more vigorous legislative oversight, substantial fines for hospitals that fail to report doctors and making compliance with the database requirements part of the Medicare certification process.

In July, William Heisel , a longtime health care reporter who is now a communications officer at the Institute for Health Metrics and Evalution in Seattle, offered his own solutions to prevent this sort of problem from repeatedly occurring: Have journalists follow up on recommendations and legislation years later to evaluate their implementation and/or success. By doing so, reporters could perform the essential function of holding government accountable. Had anyone checked to see whether hospitals were indeed reporting dangerous docs to the NPDB, they would have learned that hospitals were failing miserably. (Heisel kindly praises our report, saying that we performed “an invaluable service.”  Thanks!)

In addition,  Robert M. Wachter, M.D., read our report and offered his own ideas about how the doctor reporting system could be fixed. Peer review, he argues, is not working. Not only do doctors have a sort of “fraternity of medicine” whereby they loathe ratting one another out, they also are painfully aware of how much time and effort it takes to be a doctor, which makes them reluctant to take away one’s livelihood.

Dr. Wachter concludes:

A profession is [a] group of individuals with special knowledge, who are granted privileges by society in deference to their expertise and in exchange for self-regulation. When thousands of hospitals can go 20 years without disciplining a single physician on their medical staff, our status as a profession is called into question.

In the end, peer review is about answering one deceptively simple question: Is it more important to protect problem physicians or vulnerable patients? If we can’t answer that question correctly, we should not be surprised when the Sid Wolfes [director of Public Citizen’s Health Research Group] of the world call us to task, nor when we find ourselves under an unpleasant media, legislative, and regulatory microscope. Professions don’t need that kind of outside scrutiny to do the right thing, but we just might.

Thank you, Dr. Wachter, for shedding some light on how doctors view the system and revealing one more way in which improvements must be made to ensure the safety of our medical system.

Advertisements

Share this:

  • Email
  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Reddit

Like this:

Like Loading...

Related

Posted in Consumer Protection, Health, Uncategorized | Tagged health & safety, hospital report, peer review |

  • Follow Our Tweets!

    Error: Twitter did not respond. Please wait a few minutes and refresh this page.

  • Support Our Work

  • Socialize With Us

  • Categories

  • Visit Our Other Sites

    • Public Citizen Read our reports and publications
    • Eyes on Trade Challenging globalization
    • Citizen Energy Fighting for a sustainable future
    • Law & Policy Justice for consumers
    • Texas Vox Activism from the Lone Star state
    • Worst Pills An independent pharma watchdog
  • Recent Comments

    Wellescent Health Bo… on The Midmorning Refill: Nancy P…
    Democracy Now! discu… on When it comes to cheating the…
    Marcia Everett on The Midmorning Refill: Mother…
    David Peterson on When it comes to cheating the…
    otto mandarin on Weissman: It’s not a pre…
  • Flickr Photos

    Public Citizen and supporters protest Vice President Mike Pence outside his "Tax Prom" on November 16, 2017Public Citizen President Robert Weissman protests Vice President Mike Pence outside his "Tax Prom" on November 16, 2017The Corruption Cleanup mascot joins Public Citizen to protest Vice President Mike Pence outside his "Tax Prom" on November 16, 2017
    More Photos
  • access to justice Activism arbitration Avandia bailout banking big oil big pharma BP campaign contributions Campaign Finance campaign finance reform Chamber of Commerce Citizens United Citizens United v. FEC Climate Change Congress Consumer Protection corporate power credit cards DISCLOSE Act Don't Get Rolled economics economy elections Energy energy & climate EPA Ethics fair trade FDA fec financial reform first amendment free trade global warming gop government reform gulf of mexico Halliburton Health health & safety health care health care delivery health care reform Jon Stewart Lobbying lobbying and government ethics lobbyists McCain-Feingold medical malpractice money in politics nafta obama offshore drilling oil oilspill oil spill Open Government petition pharma political ads political advertising political contributions politics Rally to Restore Sanity scotus single-payer stephen colbert Supreme Court Transparency Transportation U.S. Chamber of Commerce wall street wto
  • Archives

  • Meta

    • Register
    • Log in
    • Entries RSS
    • Comments RSS
    • WordPress.com
  • NetworkedBlogs
    Blog:
    Public Citizen - Citizen Vox
    Topics:
    progressive, reform, politics
     
    Follow my blog
  • Advertisements

Create a free website or blog at WordPress.com.

WPThemes.


loading Cancel
Post was not sent - check your email addresses!
Email check failed, please try again
Sorry, your blog cannot share posts by email.
%d bloggers like this: